|
Mystical
Physics had its start in the days of the Counterculture,
the 1960s. Two main early gurus of the movement were Fritjof
Capra and Fred
Alan
Wolf. The basic thrust of this movement had two
prongs: (1) Modern theoretical physics was clearly
demonstrating that the religious traditions of the Far
East were entirely valid and completely consistent with
the fundamental concepts of physics. (2) All "paranormal"
phenomena had a scientific basis, especially provided by
very "recent" developments in quantum physics and
quantum field theory. Thus, for example, many therapies
dismissed as medical quackery could be shown to be able
to actually cure patients, because they had a firm basis
in quantum physics! In fact, "Quantum
Healing" soon became an explicit form of medical
quackery, spinning off from this nonsense... and it is
totally indeed all nonsense,
with no basis in fact. Half-baked semi-mystical ideas were sometimes expressed by a few founders of quantum physics in the era 1925 - 35, but the heyday of modern mystical physics spanned the era from about 1970 to 2000. Since then the ideas generally have survived only in medical quackery and in internet memes! But since only a tiny fraction of the US population has ever had a course in modern physics, the "physics" most people encounter on the internet, even in "news" stories, is ludicrous nonsense based very often on the myths invented during the mystical physics era. |
| |
These ideas about physics providing a basis for belief in pseudoscience came at precisely the wrong time... that is, they were inspired by a completely wrong concept of fundamental physics, usually attributed to Geoffrey Chew. At the time, more than 100 "fundamental" particles had been discovered, with dozens more added each year. No one at the time had any correct notion of how to deal with this situation, including Chew. His idea, called "Nuclear Democracy," was that such particles were not made of anything, had no constituents. Each particle was a kind of linear combination of all the others. This idea led absolutely nowhere! The problem was solved by the great theoretical physicist Murray Gell-Mann, who came up with the quark model for baryons and mesons. Yuval Ne'eman came up with the same idea independently. The work of many other great physicists, awarded many Nobel prizes over the years, led directly to the Standard Model of particles and fields, which has been the basis of all further progress in fundamental physics for the past half century! It has met every experimental test with flying colors. The mystical physics gurus were inspired by a wrong and sterile physics idea, an idea that led to a completely blind alley. But there was still no connection between this wrong idea and any form of mysticism or religion. The world's many Holy Books were written by people who had no idea what happened to the sun at night. They knew (and cared) nothing about how the world might work. Such ancient, multi-authored works do not contain anything recognizable as physics. In fact, religious people today as often as not consider physics and biology the greatest enemies of any and all religion.
| |
The US population is woefully ignorant of all aspects of science, and especially of physics, a fact that has been lamented at nearly every level of society since 1957. I would shudder to guess at what percent of the population has any factual knowledge of quantum physics, since only junior-level physics majors at large universities ever get a detailed introductory course in that vital topic. But one of the most common tactics of pseudoscience is appeal to ignorance. The pseudoscience advocate can safely assume that his or her intended audience knows nothing factual whatsoever about quantum physics, and can safely misrepresent it in any way convenient for the purpose. For the same reason, most anything you see on the internet about quantum physics is ignorant nonsense, unless it comes from a university professor of physics, or a researcher at a national laboratory. Here are some common bits of nonsense:
|
|
|
|
Contrary to the nonsensical illustration in the meme, the single slit pattern does not depend in any way on who is looking at it, but is shaped entirely by the probability amplitude wavelength of the beam particles and the width of the slit, while the double slit pattern also depends on the distance between the two slits.
There is no superposition of classical systems (which are the detectors in the experiment!) |
|
Rory Coker in about 1970 |
|
|
Another concept used without any contact with reality in pseudoscience is "quantum entanglement." It is actually neither very surprising, nor in any way "supernatural." Imagine you have a favorite pair of socks, unique in some way, with special meaning to you. When going on a fairly extended trip, you always try to make sure these socks are in your suitcase. But suppose on one trip, when you first open your suitcase and unpack, only ONE of the socks is to be found. At that instant, you know that the other sock is still back in your sock drawer at home, no matter how far you have traveled from that home. Before you looked in the suitcase, you assigned the probability that both socks were in the same place to be 100%. The instant you find only one sock, the probability that both socks are together changes to 0%. This is just probability at work. An update of information instantly updates probabilities. In physics experiments, two photons are placed in a state where their intrinsic spins are opposite, but as usual in quantum physics, this state is a superposition of (1/2){photon 1 spin up plus photon 2 spin down} and (1/2){photon 1 spin down plus photon 2 spin up}. The instant you measure photon 1's spin and find it to be up, you know the other photon, no matter how far away it is at that time, is spin down. This happens because the essence of quantum physics is probability. Measurements always create information that did not exist in nature before the measurement. Of course in the sock example, the socks are classical objects and never in a superposition of states, but like the photons they are a correlated pair, and in the travel situation, observation of one sock instantly gives you new information about the other sock, which is not present, just as in the actual experiments with two correlated photons. |
| |
In 2020 less than 40% of the US adult population reported a “great deal” of confidence in scientists. The news media tend to report, not progress in basic fields of science, but rather sensational and obviously wrong speculations by various strange individuals. This is particularly an acute problem in the reporting of advances in physics. The average American has almost no knowledge of physics, other than the near-nonsense that is presented by the mass media. This makes it very difficult for physicists to communicate the basic facts we know about the universe we inhabit, and how it works.
AI Summary:
Mystical and pseudoscientific claims about physics, often
termed "quantum mysticism" or "quantum woo," misinterpret
and misrepresent quantum physics concepts to suggest that
consciousness somehow creates reality, that subatomic
particles possess conscious intention, or that spiritual
phenomena are somehow scientifically validated. Proponents
often argue that "quantum entanglement" proves universal
interconnectedness or that observers somehow "collapse" and
therefore manifest the "reality" they experience, when in
fact quantum effects disappear at macroscopic scales due to
decoherence... states no longer superpose.
Some Common Mystical Physics
Claims:
👻 Consciousness Collapses
Reality: Claiming there is an "observer effect" in
quantum mechanics, which means human thought dictates
physical reality, an idea often interpreted as "creating
your own personal reality".
👻 Interconnectedness
(Entanglement): Using the existence of quantum-scale
entanglement to argue that all things are constantly
communicating and connected, equating this to telepathy or
spiritual oneness, or all psychic powers, or prophecy, or
Manifesting, or many other pseudoscience themes.
👻 Quantum Healing:
Proponents suggest that (imaginary) "quantum energy" can be
mentally directed to reverse aging or heal diseases
instantly.
👻 Everything is Illusion/Energy: The belief that solid, physical matter does not truly exist, but is simply forms of energy being manipulated by human thought.
👻 Quantum Brain
Functions: The claim that the brain is a quantum
computer, somehow making consciousness a fundamental, and
non-physical force within the universe.
Physics Facts:
⚛ The "Observer" Fallacy:
In physics, an "observation" is any interaction
between physical systems (like a particle collision), not an
"observation" by a conscious human mind.
⚛ The Scale Problem
(Decoherence): Quantum effects (such as state
superpositions) are incredibly fragile and disappear
instantly when they interact with the surrounding
environment. A warm, wet human brain cannot sustain quantum
states.
⚛ Misinterpreted Math: While
the entire universe can be formally, mathematically
represented as a single state function, this does not in any
sense indicate that every part of the universe is
practically or meaningfully connected. The only long-range
force in our universe is gravity, which propagates at the
speed of light.
⚛ "Energy" Nonsense:
The term "energy" was invented by Thomas
Young in the early 19th Century, to describe a
mathematical book-keeping approach that tracks the work done
on or by a system. It is a number, but not the number of
anything! In pseudoscience "energy" seems to be imagined as
a spiritual, mystical glow which radiates from all
objects! The 19th Century term "vibration" is
similarly misused.
⚛ These "mystical physics" claims are entirely pseudoscience, using genuine scientific terms merely to prop up metaphysical desires to bridge the infinite gap between valid physics and vague spiritual ideologies. The aim is to replace the indifferent external universe with our own purely selfish whims and desires. The universe of magical thinking is entirely human-centric.