WHAT'S A GHOST?
  • A SPIRIT? They are by definition invisible, intangible, and can't affect inert matter in any way.

  • A SOUL? They are by definition invisible, intangible, and can't affect or inhabit inert matter.

  • AN ASTRAL BODY (SPIRIT DOUBLE?) They are by definition invisible, intangible, and can't affect or inhabit inert matter.

  • ECTOPLASM? Whatever that is, according to spirit mediums, it can only issue from a human body, and is clearly visible coming out of the body. It can affect inert matter like an actual limb of a living being.

  • A DEMON PRETENDING TO BE A PERSON KNOWN TO BE DEAD? Shakespeare's Hamlet worried about this possibility, but it is rarely suggested.

  • IF A GHOST IS WEARING CLOTHES, are the clothes ghosts of sheep or of cotton plants? If the clothes are of synthetic fabric, how can they appear as ghosts when they were never alive?



  • The stereotypical European/American image of ghosts wearing just a sheet comes from the once fairly common practice of burying corpses naked, wrapped in a shroud or sheet.

    The very meaning and significance of the word "ghost" has changed tremendously over time. So much so, that on average the word has no real meaning at present. The ghosts of non-Western cultures are unrecognizably different from the standard ghosts of US movies and TV. It is no exaggeration to say that ghosts in the US and England are entirely a creation of the media, like UFOs... indeed, ghosts are a kind of indoor version of a UFO.  Anything perceived as in any way unusual, inside a house, is declared to be the work of a "ghost," whatever that is.  Also, like UFO abductions, many ghost sightings seem to be vivid dreams. It should be no surprise then that the history of ghost photographs is as old as photography itself. The myth is far more deathless than the ghost itself.



    "Ghosts" in non-European cultures have almost no relation or connection to the standard representations in US media. For example, Tibetan ghost monsters include hungry ghosts, malevolent spirits, demons, and wrathful protector deities, all of which result from a blend of traditional folklore with Buddhist cosmology, and can manifest as either harmful monsters or as helpful natural forces personified. More generally within the traditional belief systems of most world cultures, ghosts have been used as supernatural explanations for natural events, especially weather patterns, storms, forest fires, epidemics, climate changes, and environmental forces in general.  These narratives often mix local traditional beliefs about death, the spirit world, and the unpredictability of nature, serving both as cultural explanations and as coping mechanisms in the face of continual uncertainty in a hostile natural world.   Ghosts more similar to the modern concept appear in the literature and art of classical Greece and Rome, and are the root of the modern ghost mythology.

    Instead of looking for ghosts, why not just listen? As discovered by Sarah Estep in the 1970s all you need is a consumer-grade audio recorder. Just record an empty room and play back at full volume, listen to the noise, and find patterns. You can hear not only ghosts but also angels and space aliens, according to her. You can also use video recordings of non-digital TV channels not occupied by TV stations. And much, much more. Ghost hunting with high-tech (and bogus) detection equipment has become almost as popular as dowsing.

    Class web page on ghosts and poltergeists!

    BELIEF IN GHOSTS VERSUS CONFIDENCE IN SCIENCE

    Next