ORIGIN OF MATTER?
We do not dwell in the Palace of Truth. But, as was
mentioned to me not long since, “There is a time coming when all
things shall be found out.” I am not so sanguine myself,
believing that the well in which Truth is said to reside is
really a bottomless pit. --- Oliver Heaviside, Electromagnetic
Theory, Volume I; p. 1; The Electrician Pub. Co.,
London. 1893.
 |
Andrei Sakharov
(1921 - 1989):
"... Like faint glimmers of light in the dark, we have
emerged for a moment from the nothingness of the dark
unconsciousness of material existence. We must make good
the demands of reason and create a life worthy of
ourselves and of the goals we only dimly perceive." |
The very early universe
could have consisted only of bosons. Bosons can create
fermion-antifermion pairs at high energy density, but they would
presumably rapidly annihilate back to bosons. Yet we live in a
universe where dark matter, baryons and leptons do exist, with
no antiparticle counterparts anywhere, and the ratio, for
example, of baryons to photons is around 6 × 10−10.
Because the amount of dark matter is comparable to the amount of
baryons, it is tempting to think they have a common origin. In
order to be “frozen in,” matter must have originated within the
first 10−12 sec of the universe. [In what
follows, we use B for baryon number instead of our usual A.]
Sakharov Conditions for
Fermion Synthesis:
• There must be processes
that directly violate conservation of B and L.
• There must be both C- and
CP-violating processes.
• The interactions must
occur beyond thermal equilibrium.
(For example C-violating
processes could produce excess “handedness,” but direct CP
violation is needed to generate excess fermions. Since
the very early universe was expanding and cooling
explosively, the last condition is obviously met
automatically.)

Since the early 1970s, theorists
have sought descriptions which unify the strong interaction
with the electroweak interaction, and even more ambitions
descriptions which include gravity. The record so far is a
record of total, absolute and complete failure. Such
ideas seem misguided, and tend to muddle efforts to imagine
processes that could result in net amounts of dark and
ordinary matter.
Contents of a cubic meter of
"empty" space in today's universe: ![]()

There are high energy
electroweak processes in the Standard Model that, for
example, convert
anti-leptons to quarks, but in those nonperturbative
processes, B - L is conserved. There is a consensus that not
nearly enough CP violating processes are known to understand
fermion production in the early universe. In fact the
estimate based on existing CP-violating processes is about
10 powers of 10 too small! One suggested solution is to
concentrate on generating leptons and depend upon B - L
conserving processes to convert many leptons to quarks.
However, what about dark matter? It is highly suggestive
that Ωb/Ωdm is about 0.2. Presumably
dark matter and baryons need a unified theory of their
origins... difficult to accomplish when the nature of dark
matter is unknown! Two energy scales of interest in trying
to think up processes are the Planck Scale, about 2.4 × 1018
GeV, and the “Grand Unification” scale of about 2 × 1016
GeV. At the Planck scale all four interactions might have
equal coupling constants, while at the GUT scale the strong,
weak and electromagnetic coupling constants might all be
equal. Or not. And essentially nothing is known
about these regions. It's not surprising, then, that
a lot of attention has been directed to the electroweak
scale of only 250 GeV, and to the consequences of the
breaking of electroweak symmetry. This is the only
actual "unification" transition we have ever seen! A
very interesting SM solution to the EW field equations shows
up around 100 GeV!
|
 |
The “sphaleron”
(slick) state is a formal solution to the electroweak field
equations that is valid at sufficiently high density and
temperature. In this state, quarks can convert to
antileptons, but antiquarks cannot convert directly to
leptons. These are actual legitimate SM processes conserving
B - L. If the whole process is viewed as a first-order phase
transition, resulting from broken EW symmetry, the basic
idea would work extremely well... if there were enough
CP-violating processes known. But there are not.
Also the Higgs plays a key role in such phase transitions,
and not enough is known about the Higgs currently to hope to
do realistic calculations.
|
 |
Recent calculations (2024) are
strongly suggesting that the origins of matter occur in
several stages, some of which come along fairly late in the
early history of the universe, and not from the hypothetical
very early "baryogenesis" and "leptogenesis" processes. This
would mean that the early processes needed to produce far
less matter than previously thought. There is general
agreement that baryogenesis and leptogenesis are separate
issues... at the end of it all we need 6 pointlike quarks
and 6 pointlike leptons. What are the roles in all of
this for right-handed neutrinos and the Higgs boson?
Where and how do the fermions of dark matter get
generated? Where did the CP-violating processes vanish
to?
 |
 |
A very popular time to
attribute the origin of matter to is the era immediately
following the collapse of the inflation field into
particles. At first these would be bosons of huge mass, but
after a cascade of very rapid decays as the universe
reheated, it is tempting to imagine processes that create
quarks and leptons. The problem is that “imagination” is
about all you have to work with, at that era, the very
beginning of the “hot Big Bang” itself.
BARYOGENESIS
LEPTOGENESIS
ORIGIN OF MATTER
DARK ENERGY
INFLATION
STRINGS????
Back